Skip to content

Is Freedom Overrated?

by Caleb Backholm

On Thursday, May 18 2023, Caleb Backholm published this on his Facebook page:

Is freedom overrated? 

“Let my people go,” is perhaps the most well-known political statement in history. It’s about Israel being called out of slavery in Egypt. 

I’ve heard it a thousand times, but not until recently did I notice there’s more to it. 

Every time God uses the phrase “let me people go,” it is followed with the words “…that they may serve me.”

“Let my people go that they may serve me.” 

 Over and over He says it in the story, and every time it is the same. “…that they may serve me.”

In this story, the children of Israel were not being freed for freedom’s sake alone; they were being freed for service in a greater cause. 

Today, in this day of “my truth– my body– my choice,” if you were to ask people what the purpose of freedom is, how many would answer “to serve God” or even just “to serve?”

Nearly none, I imagine. Freedom is the ability to do what you want, many would say.

Yet it is clear in the story that God didn’t free the Hebrews so that they could live the way they wanted. He freed them so that they could live the way *He* wanted. That’s a big difference.

It almost sounds un-American, but I believe this story underscores the truth that freedom is not a good goal by itself. What we do with that freedom makes all the difference in the world.

Here’s a good definition of freedom. “Freedom is both the desire and the ability to do what we ought to.” Without the desire, the ability is pointless. Without the ability, the desire is frustrating. It takes both.

Consider the drug addict freed to take drugs, or not, in a very libertarian society. Free, sure, but not really. Not while his own desire for drugs ravages his mind and body. 

Likewise, we are free to cheat on our spouses. 

We are all free to poison all our relationships with destructive words and behaviors. 

Heck, some cities have even freed people to steal, as long as the value isn’t too high. 

But these freedoms aren’t freedoms at all because these desires cause harm when followed. They are still Egypt.

We have lots of freedom of ability in this country. The pursuit of hedonism and pleasure is a form of freedom, but if freedom is an unconstrained forest fire, free to destroy every good thing it touches, what good is that? 

Inherently, we all know we should serve something greater than ourselves, but the problem is post-modern society implicitly teaches that there is nothing greater than ourselves. Serve something greater, and there is nothing greater.

No wonder people are going crazy.

The cheetah was built to run, and the eagle for the skies. 

The Exodus story reminds us that we humans were built for service to God. 

He is greater. The awesome thing about God is that He knows and loves us more and better than we do ourselves. Knowing and following Him is true freedom.  

Another way to look at it is a form of voluntary indentured servitude, but not servitude to any man, but to the One who knows exactly what is best for us. Though counterintuitive, exchanging our allegiance to the god of self for the God of Everything is actually an upgrade in liberty. 

That explains the great paradox of Romans 6 which states that only the slaves of Christ are truly free. 

Let my people go…

…that they may serve me.

That’s freedom worth pursuing.

Thanks, Caleb! You’ve hit upon and have described the essence of what authentic freedom and liberty are! This sounds “un-American” to modern American ears because 21st-century Americans have embraced a different definition of freedom than the one you’ve written about. The truth is that America’s Founding Fathers understood the ideas you’ve highlighted, and they upheld them. These are the ideals we need to recapture and reimplement if we are to remain a free nation!

How are freedom, rights, liberty, and duty related? Go here for more information and insight. Also go here.